Connected Home
Home   

Networking   

Home Controls   

Mobile   

Home Office   

Audio   


Home Theater   

Xbox   

N-Gage   

Search   

Forums   

June 14, 2001  |  Paul Thurrott  |  Getting Connected
Break Through the Digital Video Entry Barrier

The problem with most digital media, frankly, is the barrier of entry, which has several levels. Digital media—be it audio, photography, or video—is expensive in some cases, but it's also confusing, requiring a vast array of knowledge to perform the simplest tasks. One might be a CD music aficionado, for example, but what are the chances that one then understands the differences between encoding and ripping or the costs and benefits of various bit-rates? What's MP3, and how does it compare to the Windows Media formats? How do you make your own music CDs? Etc.

When we talk about digital video, a number of similar issues crop up immediately, and unfortunately, they're exponentially more complicated than anything in digital music or photography. Like many of you, I'm just getting my feet wet, but I've produced a couple of low-quality videos for my son's Web site recently, and I hope to be able to archive my home videos on the computer soon. Here's what I've learned.

Hardware-wise, you can get started with an analog camcorder (e.g., 8mm, VHS, VHS-C) or VCR and some sort of hardware interface for the computer. The interface could be a USB dongle (low-quality), a FireWire-based solution (medium-quality), or a dedicated PCI card, such as the Dazzle Digital Video Creator II device I'm using and strongly recommend. The type of hardware you select determines the quality of the end product: For example, USB-based solutions are typically limited to 320 x 240 video, adequate for the Web, but not for a finished VHS tape. USB dongles, of course, are much cheaper than FireWire and PCI solutions and companies such as Belkin offer excellent solutions. But if you're serious about getting into digital video, a higher-end device, such as the $250 Dazzle, is definitely a smart buy, and you can still create low-end Web videos with such a product.

A number of readers expressed dissatisfaction with FireWire, and in my talks with the people at Dazzle, which supplies USB, FireWire, and PCI devices, they corroborated FireWire's inability to transfer DVD-quality video to and from a camera. Most digital camcorders today do include a FireWire interface, of course, and Apple Computer (which owns the FireWire brand name) is pushing this standard as the way to go, but I can't recommend it. FireWire cards seem to be a hit-or-miss proposition on Windows 2000 also. For the best bandwidth, and the best results, stick to a dedicated device such as the Dazzle I'm using, even if you already have a digital video camera. The PCI card connects to an external module with a variety of inputs and outputs, such as RCA jacks and S-Video, so you're going to get the highest quality possible, based on the hardware you use.

In my case, that's a low-end mono 8mm camcorder at the moment, although I'm hoping to experiment with VHS and DVD players soon, and then move up to a digital camcorder, which will offer a better picture and stereo sound, later this year. The camcorder plugs into the Dazzle's external module via the RCA jacks, and then I use the bundled software—the excellent MovieStar—to record the video and audio to the computer, create clips, insert transitions (some of which are quite professional), and perform other video-editing tasks. When you produce your final movie, which can be outputted back to a VHS deck or whatever, you get to choose the format and quality, all the way from DVD-quality—720 x 480 Moving Picture Experts Group (MPEG)-2—down to something so small and ugly it's barely worth discussing. And reader Dean Flansburg tipped me off to the impending release of MPEG-4, which will offer even better picture quality in less space. Windows Media and Real formats are also available for conversion purposes.

All this movie production requires a lot of fiddling with settings, including such esoteric options as input gain for audio and the seemingly infinite number of video types that are available. As I become more proficient, I hope to produce some slicker movies with voice-overs, music tracks, and nice fades and transitions. These features are all available today in the Dazzle and other similar products; it's just a matter of spending the time and figuring it out.

On the Windows side, Microsoft includes Windows Movie Maker (WMM) in Windows Me, and a slightly newer version, WMM 1.1, will be in Whistler desktop versions as well. WMM isn't the most compelling product, especially when you compare it to Apple's iMovie 2 (free with Macs) or the software that's bundled with the Dazzle. But WMM can actually be a good place to start because it has so few options: The learning curve is that much easier, and WMM gives you immediate feedback. The little videos on my son's site were actually captured with MovieStar on Win2K and then copied over to a Whistler Beta 1 laptop, where I used WMM to combine the clips with titles I created in Microsoft Paint (I *told* you this was low-budget production). They're not great quality, of course, but they do the job for the Web. Like I said, I'm still learning.

Speaking of the Web, publishing these videos—stored in Windows Media format, incidentally—requires the Windows Media 7 (WM7) software development kit (SDK) and some knowledge of HTML. The number of skills one needs to publish a video end-to-end just keeps growing, I guess. I'll revisit this topic in the future when I know more and can make additional recommendations. In the meantime, keep the questions coming, and peruse the following Web sites for more information.



Article Information
Related Article
 •  Become a Digital Filmmaker
Find Related Articles

Email this Article

Printer-Friendly



Reader Comments    
 


Great article-I'e been trying to understand why I get lousy quality from my Hi8 camera to computer using USB. I have a 5 year old dazzle that connects to my PC using USB,how does the new dazzle digital creator connect to the PC?My goal is to take analog video,and make SVCD's of equal quality of the source.

Thanks, Steve

Steve Staiano -November 29, 2003



NEW DIGITAL DVD VIDEO CAMERA CAMCORDER i just bought one of this but am not sure how it works are they good when they say DVD does it mean you can use CD instead of VCR tape when you make a movie or record something

feldmang@rogers.com -July 20, 2005



Great review!

Name (required): -October 1, 2006


READER COMMENTS:
We want to hear what you have to say about this article!
   

Your email is only used if our editors need to contact you. It is not used or stored for any other purpose, nor posted with your comments.

Enter the text from the image below


Please refresh the page if you have trouble reading this text.




Home   |   About Us   |   Contact Us / Customer Service   |   Media Kit

Windows IT Pro   |   SQL   |   Connected Home   |   IT Library/eBooks   |   Supersite for Windows
Windows FAQ   |   WinInfo News   |   Windows IT Pro Europe   |   Office & SharePoint Pro   |   Windows Dev Pro   |   Windows Excavator

Connected Home is a division of Penton Media Inc.

Copyright © 2008 Penton Media, Inc., All rights reserved. Terms and Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing