Connected Home
Home   

Networking   

Home Controls   


Home Office   

Audio   

Visual   

Home Theater   

Xbox   

N-Gage   

Search   

Forums   

<-- prev. page     [1] 2     next page -->

December 18, 2001  |  Paul Thurrott  |  Getting Connected
Apple iPod Review

Released about a month ago, Apple's portable MP3 player—the iPod—features the same design-savvy aesthetics as the company's iBook and PowerBook G4 systems, a generous 5GB of storage space, and yes, a hefty price. But any initial misgivings about the iPod are immediately forgotten when you pull the device out of its elegant box (even the packaging is impressive) and see it firsthand. And the experience gets better, from the iPod's innovative and intuitive UI to its first-of-a-kind integration with Apple's music-jukebox software and speed-shattering FireWire connection. Frankly, I didn't know how I would react to Apple's over-hyped MP3 player until I used one. Now I would have a hard time parting with it: Consider me converted.

If you review the iPod's specifications, the device doesn't seem too impressive. It has a 5GB hard disk, but some other hard disk-based players feature much larger capacities. The iPod ships with a FireWire interface, common on Macs, but not so common on PCs; until this device shipped, portable digital-music players always relied on the more common, but suddenly pokey, USB connection. And the iPod isn't Windows compatible, at least not yet, which limits the potential market to about 5 to 10 million modern Mac users. And at $400, it hits the high end of the price range for this type of device. Sounds like a loser, doesn't it?

It isn't. Instead, the iPod is a trendsetting product that Apple's competitors are destined to copy again and again. The iPod is easily the most usable and elegant portable digital-audio player on the market. Here's why.

Design
The device looks like a work of art, with an iBook-like snowy white fascia and an industrial silver back that, sadly, is overly prone to scratching. A large white disc, or jog dial, sits prominently at the device's bottom center and is flanked by four simple buttons, with a fifth sitting in its middle. The four outside buttons are obviously labeled as menu, play/pause, previous song, and next song; the middle button is used to select items when you enable the menu. The unit's top contains three items: the FireWire connection, the headphone jack, and a lock switch so you can throw the unit in a pocket or bag and not worry about inadvertently triggering its buttons. An LCD display for the menu sits above the jog dial.

And the iPod menu—well, it's a thing of beauty that's based on the new columnar-view style in Mac OS X. When you turn on the iPod, the optionally backlit display presents a list of choices, which include Playlists, Artists, Songs, Settings, and About. To choose an option, you dial the disc with your thumb, clockwise or counterclockwise; a slight clicking sound provides additional feedback. To select an item, click the center button. This interface is immediately obvious and works surprisingly well. The jog dial speeds up as it rotates, which is important when you're scrolling through long lists of songs or artists. To move up one level in the menu, click the menu button. Simplicity.

Here's an example. Let's say you want to hear all of a certain band's music. Turn on the iPod by pressing any button, scroll to Artists, then Select. The columnar view now changes to show a selection called All, followed by an alphabetical list of each artist you've stored on the device. Scroll down and select the artist name, and the view changes to a list of that artist's albums, preceded by the now familiar All choice. Select All. If you'd like to repeat or randomly play the selection, choose Settings from the main menu, and you'll see options for Shuffle and Repeat. You can also use this menu to determine whether the backlight comes on and the duration of the light, set the display's contrast, turn the jog dial's clicking sound on or off, set a sleep timer, and perform other tasks.

The iPod is heavier than you might expect, given its size, but isn't heavy per se; it contains quality rather than unnecessary heft, as with the Creative Labs Nomad, another hard disk-based personal-audio device.

Integration
The iPod is the first portable digital-audio device that's truly integrated with digital-music software, in this case Apple's excellent iTunes. In fact, I can't review the iPod without also reviewing iTunes because the iPod relies on iTunes and won't (yet) work with any other jukebox software. Apple iTunes ships with Mac OS 9.x and X, and the iPod includes an updated version that the device requires (since the iPod shipped, Apple has updated iTunes at least once and all future versions will, of course, be iPod-compatible).

At its most basic level, iTunes provides jukebox functionality ala Media Player for Windows XP (MPXP) or Real Jukebox: The application lets you rip CD music into your music library (in this case in MP3 format only), create playlists, burn audio-mix CDs, and listen to Internet radio stations. The iTunes interface (as with those of most Apple products) is simple, clean, and easy to use, with no extra frills or dead weight. And newer versions include cool new features such as cross-fading between songs for a radio station-like effect, an equalizer with more than 20 presets, and MP3 CD-burning capabilities.



<-- prev. page     [1] 2     next page -->

Article Information
Email this Article

Printer-Friendly



Reader Comments    
 


very helpful

jimmy -May 17, 2004



if ound this site extremely helpful. i used it to find out some information for my systems and technology homework. I would definatley reccomend this site to my friends who have to also do the homework. i would like to thank all the people who input information on this site because i actually got a level 7 for my work thanks to the help on the site. I found out alot of very good information and would love to visit your site again.

Thanx alot!!!!!!!

luv XxChArLxX

XxChArLxX -December 16, 2004



aloada poo

poo poo head -December 16, 2004



Strengths: Solid construction, excellent design, click wheel a big improvement over the past touch-sensitive buttons, sound quality definitely good, small and slim.

Weaknesses: No FM radio, no built-in microphone for recording (have to purchase it separately, must pay $99 for new battery from Apple when old one loses its charge, only supports iTunes; NO WMA MUSIC! The COST 300$+ (Ouch!!)

Summary:  

When looking for an Mp3 player, I researched all the possible models to purchase. Since most of my Mp3's are CD based, not from an online store, I had no problem with gettting a WMA-only or iTunes-only player. After reading all the reviews possible, I came to the conclusion to purchase the #1 Mp3 player of all: ipod. While searching for the best deal out there my friend told me how he won one by refferring 5 friends for one of those online trials. While intrested I was like thanks but no thanks, well that was until he showed me his and the site showing it was from. Them I figured I'll give it a try since I knew well over 5 people I could talk into doing it. Most offers were a buck or free for a month anyway. Well anyway check it out for yourself because I'm a living testimony http://www.freeiPods.com/?r=14854851 When I got it, it came in very nice packaging: a cube-shaped box, NOT one of those plastic packaging which requires a jackhammer to open. Upon opening the box, I quickly transferred the ipod into a silicone case that I bought at Best Buy. I highly recommend buying a case in which you can still have access to the screen and controls without taking out the ipod, because the silver back is very prone for fingerprints and scratches. After popping the ipod into the case, I plugged it into the wall charger for its initial charge. Apple has come up with the neatest idea: simply use the same firewire cable that you use to hook ipod to your computer and plug that into the small block that goes into your wall outlet. It is really neat. (In fact, you don't need the wall charger at all to charge ipod. It charges when you plug it into your computer too.) Upon charging, I plugged it into my pc. iTunes recognized it immediately and set about to move my music collection over to it. Once done, I plugged in my Sony earphones (I've yet to touch the included Apple ones) and turned on the device. VOILA! I couldn't believe the music quality. It was unbelievable. I tinkered with the equalizer settings and found that the "Hip Hop" setting works best for me, as it brings out the bass sound nicely. I really didn't want to go to bed that night, since I was having so much fun with the ipod.

A quick thing to beware: Although you will get the "20 GB" version from the website http://www.freeiPods.com/?r=14854851 , you only get about 18.5 GB of space on the iPod itself.

My Bottom Line: After using ipod, now I know why it is so immensely popular. You will definitely not regret getting those 5 friends to sign up for those trial offfers, I know I don't.

PDitty My rview -February 7, 2005



No help you num nut

The king of Queens -November 30, 2005



"I can't review the iPod without also reviewing iTunes because the iPod relies on iTunes and won't (yet) work with any other jukebox software."

Untrue, the iPod works very well with Winamp; personally I think it's better than its integration with iTunes.

Dr4g0n -December 25, 2006


READER COMMENTS:
We want to hear what you have to say about this article!
    Acceptable Use Policy

Your email is only used if our editors need to contact you. It is not used or stored for any other purpose, nor posted with your comments.

Enter the text from the image below


Please refresh the page if you have trouble reading this text.




Home   |   About Us   |   Contact Us / Customer Service   |   Media Kit

Windows IT Pro   |   SQL Server Magazine   |   Left-Brain.com   |   Supersite for Windows   |   asp.netPRO
FAQ for Windows   |   WinInfo News   |   Windows IT Pro Europe   |   Office & SharePoint Pro   |   DevProConnections

Connected Home is a division of Penton Media, Inc.

© 2010 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement |