Connected Home
Home   

Networking   

Home Controls   

Mobile   

Home Office   


Visual   

Home Theater   

Xbox   

N-Gage   

Search   

Forums   

September 21, 2005  |  Paul Thurrott  |  Product Reviews
iPod Nano Is Almost Perfect

In Apple Takes Digital Music to New Heights, I discussed Apple's digital music strategy and explained how the company is humbling Microsoft, which sought to dominate that market by using the same strategy it employed in the PC market. Apple's dominance is tied to two products—iPod and iTunes—and a general sense of style and elegance that's simply lacking from all competitors. Until last week, Apple's control of the digital music market seemed beyond reproach. But then the company announced its unbelievable iPod nano device, which replaces the iPod mini. And although this might not seem possible, Apple's control of the digital music market is now even more secure than before. And there's nothing—absolutely nothing—that Microsoft can do about it. The iPod nano, dare I say it, is almost perfect.

The first thing that strikes you about the iPod nano—and you really need to see it in person to appreciate this—is how small it is. It's barely wider, and actually quite a bit thinner, than the iPod shuffle, but it features a gorgeous full-color screen and a standard iPod scroll wheel. It fits in the palm of your hand like a tiny, beautiful jewel, and it gathers stares and comments from onlookers like no other digital device.

There are two versions of the iPod nano: a 2GB version ($200) that holds about 400 songs and a 4GB version ($250) that holds approximately 1000 songs. You can get both versions in standard iPod white or a new black color; my 2GB test unit is black. Both devices feature the wonderfully simple color menu system that the high-end iPod uses. However, the iPod nano also includes some extras you won't find anywhere else, including a multiple-time-zone clock, a stopwatch (perfect for you music-loving athletes), and a few new games. Apple has also added the ability to synchronize Microsoft Outlook contacts and calendars, making the iPod nano a handy PIM replacement, as well.

Apple ships the iPod nano with a set of earbud headphones, a curious dock adapter that doesn't appear to do anything quite yet, and a short instruction manual. A bundled CD includes the iPod Updater software you'll need to interact with the device from Windows or a Macintosh, and iTunes 5.0, the latest version of the best jukebox application on Earth. Because the device uses a standard iPod Dock connector, you can plug it into any standard iPod charging cable, dock, or accessory, and it should just work. That dock adapter I mentioned is apparently designed to let the iPod nano work with certain third-party accessories, but I haven't had a need for it yet.

Battery life is exceptional. Apple rates the iPod nano at 14 hours playback time, and I was able to listen to it for days at a time, including the complete length of a non-stop flight from Los Angeles to Boston. Sound quality is superb, thanks to enhanced audio circuitry that first debuted in the iPod shuffle.

As I said, the iPod nano is almost perfect. Apple cheaps out by not including a carrying case or lanyard for the device; either would prevent you from simply tossing the device in your pocket and subjecting it to abuse from coins, keys, or other paraphernalia. My test unit is already scuffed up pretty severely, despite my attempts to baby it. And I've got real concerns that the skinny iPod nano could be easily killed by inadvertently sitting on it. The device is that thin.

Additionally, most of the iPod nano accessories that Apple has promised are still weeks away from shipping, which is also a shame. You can't get a lanyard, protective case, or carrying case for the device now, even if you were willing to pay extra for something that should have come in the box. Finally, I hate the name. Apple should have kept the iPod mini name, which is far more descriptive—and accurate. Apple's iPod shuffle is smaller than the iPod nano.

These are all quibbles, of course. The iPod nano is that rarest of tech devices: Immensely useful, beautiful, and desirable—all at the same time. We're getting to the point at which most new iPod purchases are probably coming from repeat customers. So, whether you already have an iPod or not, the iPod nano is a great device to consider. It just doesn't get any better than this.

Article Information
Email this Article

Printer-Friendly



Reader Comments    
 


I don't get it. With Apple's first iPod, there was a major issue with the fact that once the battery wore out, the whole iPod was ready for the trash can. Now they do it again and I haven't heard anybody show any concern. I for one am not ready to pay serveral hundreds of dollars for a product that only lasts as long as a single lithium battery. I see no excuse for this (other than consumer-disregard greed) - many other such players have replaceable batteries. It would not be at all difficult to keep the iPod Nano at its current small size and still have a battery that easily slides out and is replaced - much as is done with hearing aids.

Steve -September 21, 2005



While I agree that a slide out battery would be nice, I wouldn't let it stop you from purchasing a nano. Some of the early iPods had battery problems, but those have largely been resolved. I have a 4th generation iPod and love it. My kids both have first-generation iPods, handed down from me or purchased through eBay, and they are working fine.

The battery can be replaced, at least in the previous models. I don't know about the nano.

Jim -September 21, 2005



Everyone claims Microsoft to be the evil empire because of marketing techniques! All I have to say is try to play your digital MP4 Apple proprietary music in any other digital play (Hardware or software). Apple encodes the music you download (Through Itunes) and the music rip so that it must be authorized before you can play it. This is fine I guess other than the fact that you can only use apple products to authorize "YOUR" copy write owned material. I seem to remember when the CD player came out I could use my CD in any device I wanted. SO please tell your readers this before you spread the bliss of apple. OH yea, don’t forget the only place to fix an apple is at apple so have fun with that.

PS I used to get my music at iTunes and use an Ipod then I found that all my music I paid for could not be played through winamp(without addins that dont always work), meidaplayer, realplayer, Etc, etc......

Apple come on!!!! -September 21, 2005



I have a 3rd generation Ipod with a dead battery that apple won't replace. I am not going to give them a 2nd chance. Plus their proprietary software prohibits me from using the songs that I have paid for on other pc's. I will never buy another apple ipod EVER again.

Andy -September 21, 2005



I love my iPod Mini and would like a Nano - even with the Apple-esque issues of non-replacable battery etc. What I just don't get, is how every time Microsoft moves someone cries foul (e.g. when Real Networks got the EU to force Microsoft to produce a version of Windows without Media Player that no-one wants to buy - which wouldn't be so bad if the Real Networks product wasn't a bug-ridden piece of spyware), but Apple can hold on to a big chunk of the digital media market with its proprietary iTunes service, AAC files and iPods and everyone says "wow - isn't this great". It seems to me that it's about time someone forced Apple to open up iTunes and AAC to other media players. Oops. Never gonna happen - because that would be the end of the Apple monopoly and Microsoft would step in ;-)

Mark Wilson -September 21, 2005



I have the white nano - it simply rocks. I chose the white over the black due to the concerns I had over scratching. The dude at bestbuy showed me his - having been in his, and a couple of associates pockets for a week - it looked like it had been dragged through a hedge backwards....

As paul mentioned, the battery life is indeed incredible - after a couple of journeys from Colorado to the East coast, you appreciate a solid battery. As for those of you with concerns about the battery giving up the ghost in a year or two, I think a replacement battery from Apple, costing approx $50-$90 is not too much of an expense considering the style, form and perfectness of the device.

http://www.utahsaint.com - my thoughts on the nano.

UtahSaint -September 21, 2005



While I consider the Ipod a wonderful device it has one devastatingly huge drawback. That is the fact that music into the Ipod is a one way trip. Some of us have libraries of 10,000 plus songs and desire to use the device for not only an entertainment device but a way to back up a valuable music collection. It does me no good to dump all my music into a device that I cannot get back out in case of an all out hard drive crash. I pay for my music with hard earned dollars and do not appreciate Apple attempting to dictate to me how I handle it once I purchase it. I don't care how small the bloody thing gets, if I cannot retrieve my music back out of it when I want to it becomes useless to me.

Shaun -September 21, 2005



I miss FM radio functionality

Max BrainBox -September 22, 2005



You can actually retrieve your music if your hard drive crashes - it happened to me. Apple's "security feature" that "protects" the iPod music actually just hides the files. If you have windows, you can go to the folder properties and tell it show hidden. If you have a mac, get a program called TweakFreak. With it you press one button and voila. What once was hidden is now revealed.

Jeff -September 22, 2005



I think Microsoft can do something. Get the PMP (protableMediaPlayer)as cheap, reliable, and well designed (microsoft branded, of course, no third-branded) as iPod is. Then give it versatile functionality (no hacks to make it work) good battery life, and a non-subscription service for downloading content (pay for download). Release a MediaCenter CE version and be happy. They can do it.

Boolean22 -September 23, 2005



Shaun: The easiest way to get your music back out is not to get it back out at all.

You have a COMPLETE copy of your music library sitting right there on your hard drive. Hard drive space is plentiful.

Simply make a duplicate of your iTunes music folder and keep it somewhere. Or if you like, select all of your song files in iTunes and export them to one large folder somewhere else (this will remove iTunes underlying folder structure and you'll have all the files in one place).

If you have a 2nd hard drive, just put your backup there. If you have an external hard drive, even better. And you can also burn all of your music files to media such as DVD-R for extra safety.

If your original hard drive dies, or you lose the music folder, you can simply run iTunes, start over and re-import all of your music files into a new library, using the 2nd/external hard drive/DVD-R as the source. All of your music will be intact.

Dave -September 23, 2005



> All I have to say is try to play your digital MP4 Apple proprietary music in any other digital player.

I'm not sure exactly what this kind of statement is supposed to prove. I can make the statement:

"All I have to say is: Try to play your digital WMA Microsoft proprietary music in the digital players which have the overwhelmingly largest market share, and they don't work."

> Apple encodes the music you download (Through Itunes) and the music rip so that it must be authorized before you can play it.

With WMA: Non-iTunes music stores also encode the music you download so that it must be authorized before you play it.

And so, your point is...?

> This is fine I guess other than the fact that you can only use apple products to authorize "YOUR" copy write owned material.

With WMA: This is fine other than the fact that you can only use non-Apple products to authorize "your" copyright-owned material.

So...?

> I seem to remember when the CD player came out I could use my CD in any device I wanted.

These aren't CD players.

CDs were originally (and effectively) copy-protected due to the fact that the technology didn't exist to make copies. The recording industry, ironically enough, didn't think far enough ahead to realize that some day, this would be a small issue to deal with.

There was a universal standard of "copy protection" inherent in CDs and CD players. Yes, you could record a tape from a CD, but who wanted to do that? (Loss of quality). And even if it happened, nobody cared. Lower quality plus loss of random access to songs plus continued deterioration with each generation of copy made.

> OH yea, don’t forget the only place to fix an apple is at apple so have fun with that.

The most common "repair" issue for an iPod would be the battery. You seem to think that Apple is the only source for replacement batteries.

Wrong.

Other than that, your point is...? With the huge numbers (many millions) of iPods sold in recent history, I think we all would have heard of significant repair issues (other than battery replacement, and we've covered that already). What are the numbers, 21 million iPods out there, total, and this is predicted to more than double over the next year?

What is it, exactly, that you'd be worried about getting fixed?

> PS I used to get my music at iTunes and use an Ipod then I found that all my music I paid for could not be played through winamp(without addins that dont always work), meidaplayer, realplayer, Etc, etc......

Before you purchased your music, you should have been aware of how it could be used, if you'd bothered to read any of the documentation/help that comes with iTunes, or if you'd taken the time to do any research about this on the web; or by reading articles in magazines; or news/magazine reviews; etc.

There are no secrets or surprises here, this has all been written up ad-nauseum over the past few years.

Dave -September 23, 2005



I cannot believe people are continuing to whine about the non-replaceable battery "issue". My 1st-gen iPod, purchased May 2002, is finally showing it's age. The battery doesn't last as long as it used to. Still, I figure it'll be another year before it gets to be a problem. And then?

Well, I'll get a new one! It's a 1st-gen iPod, an ancient relic! I'd love to replace it now, but my cheap-sense won't let me replace something that still works.

I don't think the battery-complainers understand just how long 3 years is in "gizmo-time". By the time the battery dies on your iPod, chances are near 100% that there will be something much more exciting on the market and you won't want your old iPod anymore.

LordRobin -September 23, 2005



According to the information I have, there are plenty of third-party cases available - even ruggedized ones for the iPod Nano. So I would have to question this statement. That Apple should provide such is a question of debate. I personally think it is great for them to allow third-parties such a product development space.

"Additionally, most of the iPod nano accessories that Apple has promised are still weeks away from shipping, which is also a shame. You can't get a lanyard, protective case, or carrying case for the device now, even if you were willing to pay extra for something that should have come in the box. Finally, I hate the name. Apple should have kept the iPod mini name, which is far more descriptive—and accurate. Apple's iPod shuffle is smaller than the iPod nano."

Dr. Budo -September 23, 2005



There is NEVER a shortage of iPod accessories... go down to any big box store and you'll see a WALL of accessories for all different kinds of iPods (all w the same connector)

And Apple always designs a few for launch of any new model

Paul whines that apple cheaped out on a carrying case.. when did they ever ship a carrying case.. back in 2001 maybe? they shipped a belt clip with the iPod mini.. but.. you gotta get something.. or you could just.. put your keys in your 'non ipod' pocket.. hell put your nano in the stopwatch pocket..

mike -September 23, 2005



Regarding the battery issue: Don't throw that iPod away! Go to:

http://eshop.macsales.com/Catalog_Page.cfm?Parent=1225&ref=Google%20iPod%20Battery%20General&title=iPod%20Batteries%20%26%20Power%20Adapters

...and replace that battery. I've done three different people's iPods, including my ownm with this replacement and it is awesome. Easy, too. At $30, it makes a lot of sense, and I get better battery life now than I did when my 2G iPod was brand new! Don't add to the landfill. If you still want a new one, replace the battery and give your old (now upgraded) iPod to someone you love...

___

Concerning Mr. Thurrott's fears about breaking the nano by sitting on it, he should read this comical Arstechnica review/torture test here:

http://arstechnica.com/reviews/hardware/nano.ars/3

Quoting ArsTechnica : "Our first test consisted of placing the iPod nano on a solid wood chair and sitting on it, as people are prone to do from time to time. As you can guess, this 'test' yielded basically zero damage results—so little, in fact, that we didn't even take pictures."

After the nano passed all "normal" stress tests with flying colors, they ran over it with a car. It still played despite a broken screen. So they ran over it again! It still played!

iPoditude -September 23, 2005



It's Microsoft's fault... no it's Apple's fault... blah, blah. It doesn't matter whose camp you fall into or support. These two are fierce competitors who REFUSE to cooperate and support each other's media platforms. And the real losers are us... music lover's who are forced to "chosse a side" to enter this wonderful world of digital media. For that reason I have not entered this world yet, even though my kids are iPod owners, but living in a Windows world on the desktop. Everyone should quit praising Apple and ripping Microsoft about this subject. We should all complain, and complain very loudly until there is cross platform support (I'd even be willing to pay for the codecs). I'd love to buy an iPod (they appear to be the best devices on the market), BUT I refuse to live in an AAC world... and I may prefer to not use iTunes as my library. So could you Microsoft and Apple execs figure out a way to come together... for the good of your respective loyal customers???

JayBird -September 26, 2005



blah, blah. It doesn't matter whose camp you fall into or support. These two are fierce competitors who REFUSE to cooperate and support each other's media platforms.

--

just one difference, apple puts out quality gear.. ms takes 5 year old ideas and ***** its customers. have a nice day.

mike -September 27, 2005



Exactly what I was referring to... I'm not going to debate the Apple vs. Microsoft story... it's old, . The point is interoperability. The windows media codecs are high quality... you can't argue with that. They are proprietary, I can't argue with that. Apples refusal to support these codecs does nothing but force it's users to the iTunes store for music. And Microsoft not supporting AAC is the same narrowminded monopolistic viewpoint. They BOTH are guilty of this. Apple clearly has the best hardware on the market for music players... and Microsoft, by the way, doesn't make gear, they are a software company.

JayBird -September 27, 2005



and no-one even mentions the price? Beats me why people are so anxious to pay this high price for less functionality than you can get from dozens of different makes and types of MP3 players coming out of Asia. Do your homework, test a few different options, and save many $. You can get replaceable batteries, better battery life, no DRM, built in radio, carry cases etc etc, and still save money

Freddy -September 28, 2005



Freddy, You mention the Asian MP3 players being cheaper. Which ones? They seem to be scrambling (from the articles I've read) to drop their price to be close to what Apple is charging for the nano.

NoFreddy -September 30, 2005



.. and Microsoft, by the way, doesn't make gear, they are a software company.

--

Your assumption as to what I meant.. not my problem

mike -October 1, 2005



Just get a 1GB player with a memory slot - heaps under $100, usually much less - just did a quick search on ebay, many around $80. 1GB memory is getting very cheap ($60 to $80, maybe less), the combination will cost significantly less than a nano, and you get many extras, like a radio etc

Freddy -October 2, 2005



Just get a 1GB player with a memory slot - heaps under $100, usually much less - just did a quick search on ebay, many around $80. 1GB memory is getting very cheap ($60 to $80, maybe less), the combination will cost significantly less than a nano, and you get many extras, like a radio etc

Freddy -October 2, 2005



apologies for double post...

Freddy -October 2, 2005



I dunno what to buy. The Ipod nano looks like a really good buy. But im not willing to have to use that itunes crap with all my WMA songs. Apple loses my biznass for their havint to use itunes to put isongs on your ipod. they can kiss my iass.

vince -October 13, 2005



Dave. you seem to forget, your paying for your music on Itunes. copyright law allows you to have a back up copy once you have a license for the media.. the Ipod is a Rip off first off you have a built in rechargeable battery which will eventually stop working and the life span decrease's each time you charge it.. when it goes you have to go back to apple because you have to open the unit to replace the battery unless you want to void your warranty... This means every year or so Apple will collect more money from you to fix your player.. Itunes is crap you cant transfer you music to CD and listen to it on your home AV system or on another PC or any other device except your Ipod.. the whole ipod itunes thing is a monopoly and all the suckers are buying ipods to look cool thats the only reason marketing hype.. Dave your a slave to marketing,,, Do yourself a favour, buy a player that supports multiple formats, has a removable battery (without having to dis- assemble your player). The Creative Zen micro is my choice, Dictaphone calendar etc etc removable battery so you can have an extra battery with you at all times... you can buy it in what ever colour you want and it wont cost you as much,, Dave most consumer DVD players will play WMA & Mp3 none of em play ACC Dave if you dont bring you player to apple to replace the battery you void your warranty You say you should have researched your player so you would know that your locked into apple when you buy music form Itunes - thats crap because most people get these as presents.. So why have apple gor a monopoly bigger that MS you talk about degradation when coping from CD to tape.. what do ya think happens when you get an Mp3\Acc file its compressed so your loosing quality there aswell, your not very clever now are you Your hole you need to use no apple products to verify wma - come on now what r ya talking about apple only make 1 type of player and 1 type of OS -- So practically everything in the PC\Mp3\ CE markets are non apple-- just think about it.. Ignorance is bliss

alan -October 20, 2005



i leik iopd nano ti si oss cool!!!!! Lsoer

Benjamin Applebaum -October 26, 2005



Apple is considerably overpriced when compared to anything Microsoft puts out. You can easily see who was able to gain market share in the past for other products. Microsoft is slow? Yes. But that is expected of any company that size. You are expecting a $285 Billion company to be as quick as a $50 Billion company.

Apple has always made their products proprietary and just, as in the past, they will once again suffer in the future because of this. The company has grown because of the IPOD. You can't make a company survive on one product. The Macs have been around forever yet they've had limited success. Why? Because apple doesn't like to open up interoperability for the sole purpose of charging more money from consumers. Yes Microsoft is a giant 'evil' corporation to many, but at the same time, its pricing schemes and interoperability have allowed much of the world to partake in the computer revolution. I don't see apple helping very much with that. Apple has always gone for the image. They convince through advertising and appealing to the senses of insecure trend stars. They don’t try to change the world; they try to earn more money by fleecing folks interested in their status or the latest cool gadget.

With that said, I bought into apple as well simply b/c they executed one smart move and were able to shut out the competition by striking a deal to get cheap memory from Samsung. That effectively destroyed any near term competition and virtually guaranteed that they could charge what they wanted for the nano. But you can bet when another giant company strikes a similar deal with the flash memory makers to get gear cheap, competition will once again kill apple---no matter how much marketing they do. The Mac will never be adopted by corporations and Apple's one successful product (the ipod) will not help keep the company on top forever.

Until then, the graphic artists and trend stars can continue to shell out money for Apple's overpriced gear which has the built in benefit of becoming obsolete or needing battery replacement.

What would be nice is if MSFT bought out creative or iriver. Now that would just kill apple and make sure that the consumers don’t have to pay exhibit amounts to replace a battery.

hova -November 5, 2005



I have been using apple products forever, and I have not once had any compatability problems. I have a third party app that lets me convert anything to almost antthing. I mostly use it for it's WMA->Mp3 then i simply convert them into m4a for itunes. As for downloaded music, dod you know that if you burn an audio cd in itunes that negates that copy protection, thus you can take it to a PC and rip it again to whatever format you want it in. As for not being able to take music off your iPod, i also have an app that does that. If you know where to look you can do anything. Your just ignorant for not trying

Apple Supporter -November 6, 2005



my ipod actually..and this is a tue story,blew up in my hands!!please help..i still havent man/ged to get the bits of melted plastic off my skin

marlon -November 13, 2005



I don't know if I shold get a nano because i want to record media player music on to it and i don't know if it is compatable please respound to my message pleaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaeaessssssssssse!

DJFDerrynoose -November 22, 2005



i think all ipods,ipod nanos, and ipod minis should be under $60 for kids.

bianca -December 11, 2005



I'm really annoyed just because of the incompatibility of IPOD with older versions of Windows (ME specifically). Preparing my grandfather's nano has been an absolute NIGHTMARE because the new software doesn't work with the old windows, and the old software and new hardware doesn't work with the newer versions of the OS.

Christ, he doesn't want to spend more money to upgrade, but it's either upgrade or the nano is useless to him. He wanted a reliable music media for work, what he got was a neverending quest for compatibility at home. Now the Architecture student/grandson has to try to put the pieces together... I DONT HAVE TIME FOR THIS!!!!!!

matt -December 26, 2005



I really want to buy a music player. I use iTunes on my PC. Buying a portable device without a replaceable battey is stupid at best and environmentally insensitive. What I want is something that 1. plays AAC files, 2. I don't care about DRM, because I don't (and won't) buy music online [i only rip my own CDs]. 3. needs a replaceable battery 4. shold have 1GB built-in 5. must be expandable with flash memory (or similar??) that can be populated via a fast interface [ie - if I have to go thru the player to load music onto flash card, and that process is half or slower than copying music straight to flash card with dedicted card reader, then forget about it].

seems like a simple idea. no where is it?

Lawrence -December 26, 2005



STFU MARLON.IM GONNA KICK YOUR TUSHY.IPOD IS TOO STEONG FOR UR HANDS.IT WOULDNT BLOW IN UR HANDS.GET SOME KNOWLEDGE

Dave -December 27, 2005



im hvaing some problems. i bought an i - pod for x-mas and i wanna download songs onto it ; but i don't wanna buy them from i - tunes because i am already paying for lime wire can anyone help me ?

dee -December 29, 2005



I think downloading is really stupid and low. I mean the artists they make a living off of YOU buying the cd's and what they are losin milloins of dollars b/c of this l0l I know you're probaly thinkin ok that doesnt mean anything toward yourslef but Karma will come plus it's ILLEGAL and you could get arrested for this crime

Khermesh -December 31, 2005



You all are a bunch of losers. Mean while i just got disney!!!!!!!!!!!

Steve Jobs -February 2, 2006



Better yet , buy a nice vintage Nakamichi cassette deck ( Dragon or ZX-9 ) and record with it from "any" source and have beautiful recordings without the compatability issues ! With this setup , I enjoy capturing music at a much better quality than mp3 . Yeah , it's tape but it will be here years from now and will not dissapear like a *****in the wind like digital files can.

Dave -February 15, 2006



YOU CAN REPLACE THE IPOD NANO BATTERY. I am going to buy one on eBay it only costs about $15.00 or LESS on eBay or some third party website for a 400mAh or 330 mAh (which costs less). I think the factory Nano comes with 300mAh so either way you end up with MORE PLAY TIME by replacing the battery. The 3rd party products which have just recently been popping up (end of feb 2006) come with tools to help you remove the old battery and replace with the batter that comes with the $15 that you paid. I will be buying one soon even though I've only used my nano for about 5 months, the battery life too low for my liking. And at $15 for much increased battery life there's nothing to lose, except maybe.. my Ipod Warranty... Haha.

Andrew Cheng -February 26, 2006



I've only used my nano for about 4 months and the battery will not hold a charge I think it is junck

paul -March 22, 2006



ITS GOOD

BRANDON -June 8, 2006



should i buy a nano?

austin -June 10, 2006



marlon you are such a total lier:(

austin -June 10, 2006



Your Comments (required):

Homey -June 12, 2006



I GOT THE PROBLEM WITH IT

Name (required): -June 12, 2006



i have a ipod mini shuffle and nano, they have all worked great but, the shuffle stoped working and the battery on the mini and the nano shouol last longer between charging.

Metallica -August 13, 2006



hello i just wana say that ipod sucks! ive had a ipod nano for about 5months now and i cant get the program to be installed on a windows me computer ive downloaded a program called ephpod it sayd it wud enable it so i cud put music onto my ipod put still it wont let me what kinda morons sell programs and or devices that cant be installed or work properly damit!.... hmm or am i the moron... lmao mail me plz if you can help me out heheh

hi -October 2, 2006



I've read through the endless battery chats but what I was taking note to are the warranties included from apple. Anyone find those worth buying? Think not. I just went into best buy and got a nano and a two year $30 replacement plan. I can't imagine how that wouldn't be a benefit. Yeah, battery replacements are cheaper than $30, but the replacement plan covers much more than just the battery. My question to all you guys out there is, how long have *your* batteries lasted for? When wondering if I should purchase a two year plan, I had *heard* that batteries can go around 1.5 years - so I figured the plan was especially worth it since Apple charges $60 for their battery replacement.

Any thoughts? I think Best Buys plan is a pretty sweet deal..

Shimmy -October 24, 2006



Don't buy an I-pod.... Geeze... The I-pod is just a fad.

Buy a Creative Zen... I have the Zen "Sleek Photo", And love it. Yes, It's a little big and heavy, but it is built well, full-featured, And is fully compatible with Windows Media Player. In fact, It will even import your WM Playlists. The only downside to it is the non-replaceable battery. (Altough my battery works like new, even after one year, and a lot of use).

Sofa King We Todd Did -November 5, 2006



Hello there,

there is a huge issue with iTunes and this is music compatibility. Register your concern with Apple by following this link:

http://www.apple.com/feedback/itunesapp.html

and pasting this text in:

"I would just like to ask whether in the next version/update of "iTunes" you will allow compatibility for other devices e.g Creative e.t.c. I believe that this would make sense for you as "iPods" have the market for portable music playing but "iTunes" is generally only used with "iPods" but if it were to be used with devices other than iPods then this great piece of software would be moved into the market for music downloads. At the moment I have downloaded around three or four albums from "iTunes Store" and can only play them on my cd player or computer. As I don't have an iPod but a name brand MP3 player I would like to be able to play my music on my MP3 player. There are many people around on the internet that would like to be able to use this feature.

The advantages of this for you as a company? >Increased status as a great company who respect their customers >More purchases through iTunes Store >More people using Apple products >Respect from people who are beginning to think of Apple as "the new microsoft"

Currently on the internet many people are clamouring for your attention on this issue here is the link to one such website: http://www.connectedhomemag.com/Audio/Articles/Index.cfm?ArticleID=47801

I searched various phrases, in google,containing the phrase "I hate <apple brand>". Here are the results of these searches:

Results 1 - 10 of about 3,780,000 for I hate apple. (0.26 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 2,760,000 for I hate ipod. (0.28 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 2,250,000 for I hate itunes. (0.28 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 2,250,000 for I hate iTunes. (0.16 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 2,760,000 for I hate iPod. (0.12 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 1,530,000 for I hate iTunes Store. (0.21 seconds)

Whereas I searched similar phrases with your competitors’ brands you still are comparitively less hated than some of your competitors but some of your products are more hated than products from your competitors:

Results 1 - 10 of about 4,910,000 for I hate windows. (0.28 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 2,290,000 for I hate linux. (0.28 seconds) Results 1 - 10 of about 1,550,000 for I hate windows media player. (0.18 seconds

On the other hand if you search for some other products you come up. In this example I searched I hate walkmans and ipods come up:

Web Images Groups News Froogle more » Advanced Search Preferences Search: the web pages from the UK Web Results 1 - 10 of about 38,600 for I hate Walkmans. (0.21 seconds) Sponsored Links I hate Players Learn How To Understand Men - And Beat Them At their Own Game! www.DatingWithoutDrama.com Sponsored Link

pricerunner.co.uk/cassetteplayers/ Great Prices on over 30 Walkmans on UK comparison site! TED Blog: 10 Reasons to Hate Your iPod Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 10 Reasons to Hate Your iPod: ... You know, a Walkman. That's it... and if they sucked, they wouldn't have ... tedblog.typepad.com/tedblog/2005/11/10_reasons_to_h.html - 68k - Cached - Similar pages

I think that you have some serious making up to do to your customers as they will leave you if you don't get your act together. I for one will not buy any music off iTunes store as it doesn't offer the compatibility that I need.

Please take note of this

Regards "

Tommy Garland -December 16, 2006



Above (Dec 26 '05) I asked about what I wanted in a perfect MP3 player. Well lo' and behold it finally exists - the Sandisk Sansa E200R series. Plays AAC files, replaceable battery, direct USB connectivity, expandable with flash memory (microSD in this case). I'm not interested in DRM files, so the Rhapsody thing is a non issue for me. This thing has everything I asked for!

lawrence -January 6, 2007



On Dec 26 '05 (above) I asked for what I thought was a simple design for a reasonable MP3 player. Well its finally here! The SanDisk Sansa E200R series - AAC file support, replacable battery, microSD flash memory expansion, direct USB support! As I said, I don't deal with DRM at all, so that's a non-issue for me. I finally have a MP3 player!

Lawrence -January 6, 2007



MY IPOD IS GOING TO BE SWEET.

RAQAYYA -January 17, 2007



Your Comments (required):

Name (required): -January 17, 2007



MY IPOD IS GOING TO BE SWEET

RAQAYYA -January 17, 2007



Hi i just got a i-pod nano. I dont know if it will work on my coputer. I have a windows me. I have a usb cord thingy so i want to know if my ipod will still work on my computer.

Nicole -February 14, 2007



Not finding replacement batteries for the NANO. It appears soldering is required. What a piece of crap. Apple wants $60 to replace it. They replace the whole unit and not the battery. Jobs is an uncool ***!

Name (required): -March 12, 2007



1: Apple replaces the whole nano when you get a new battery because that's the easiest and fastest way for them to do it. Your old nano, with a new battery, will be given to someone else - they don't scrap them.

2. If you're using Windows Me in 2007 (I could say "if you use Windows Me at all", but won't), you're being pretty dumb. Windows XP, or even Windows 2000, is much, much, much, much better - more reliable, better supported, more compatible with everything else in the world, better all around. My sympathies for your "I'm using Me, I need help doing..." is pretty limited - they don't call Windows 98/Me "Wintendo" for nothing.

Mike -April 28, 2007



it was pritty good .id rate it a 4 out of 5.

russell wade -June 2, 2007



Your Comments (required):

Name (required): -June 24, 2007



IT IZ DAT RAW

sean -June 24, 2007



Okay, hi. im 13 years old, & EVERYONE around me has an ipod nano. so i wanna get a green one. but then i came across this site.... so i wanna know one thing. can i buy a battery-charger or something that will charge up the battery so i dont have to waste money i dont have on a peice of metal-paper that sings?

Jko -July 24, 2007



I have one of those. =]

Kristin -January 4, 2008



i dont know as i dint get mine till now..but hopefully it will be nice.im not the richest person..so i cant buy hundreds and hundreds if one gets spoilt...this sucks i want a nice one but dont know which one will be good as they are expensive(to me)cause i wanna buy it with my own pocket money though it isnt neccesary!

sai aishwarya -January 29, 2008



it's perfect and la fata 2lla 3ali wala sayfa 2lla thulfekar

wessam mantash -July 21, 2008



i want one so bad

Name (required): -August 9, 2008



ok my name is sonaia and im 9 years old and i have one questions how much does it coast

sonaia -August 9, 2008



yth

amanda -August 17, 2008



well, i personally have no problem with my ipod nano. i've got one of the new chrome ones; and they're pretty snazzy. i have no problem with the charge, and i listen to it all the time. it's never died on me- i just wish i knew how to do more with it! :)

Emily -April 29, 2009


READER COMMENTS:
We want to hear what you have to say about this article!
    Acceptable Use Policy

Your email is only used if our editors need to contact you. It is not used or stored for any other purpose, nor posted with your comments.

Enter the text from the image below


Please refresh the page if you have trouble reading this text.





Home   |   About Us   |   Contact Us / Customer Service   |   Media Kit

Windows IT Pro   |   SQL Server Magazine   |   Left-Brain.com   |   Supersite for Windows   |   asp.netPRO
FAQ for Windows   |   WinInfo News   |   Windows IT Pro Europe   |   Office & SharePoint Pro   |   DevProConnections

Connected Home is a division of Penton Media, Inc.

© 2010 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement |